A sound cleaning company in San Francisco vets staff by confirming identity and work history, making a conditional job offer, and only then running a criminal background check. The company, as the employer, runs that process, and it has to follow both the city’s Fair Chance Ordinance and California’s Fair Chance Act. For an office manager, “our staff are background-checked” is the start of the conversation, not the end of it. The useful questions are what the check covers, when it happens, who it applies to, and what the company does after the hire.
Why “Background-Checked” Is Not a Complete Answer
The phrase can mean a full consumer report ordered through a screening firm, or it can mean a quick name search someone ran years ago. It says nothing about which counties were searched, whether the person who shows up tonight was included, or whether anyone has looked since the hire date. A cleaning crew often works alone in your suite, near laptops, files and supply rooms, so the detail matters. Ask the company to describe its steps in order, and listen for specifics.
Who Actually Runs the Check
The cleaning company is the employer, so the screening decisions and the legal duties sit with it. You, the client, decide what your space requires and which areas the crew may enter. You should not ask for a crew member’s report, because that file belongs to the hiring process and holds personal information. What you can reasonably ask for is a written description of the process and a named person who answers for it.
San Francisco Sets the Timing
The city’s Fair Chance Ordinance, Article 49 of the Police Code, applies to employers with five or more employees for jobs worked at least eight hours a week in San Francisco. Part-time, temporary and contingent positions are included, which describes a lot of evening cleaning work. A covered employer may not ask about arrest or conviction records until after a conditional offer of employment. If a company tells you it screens everyone before the interview, ask it to explain, because that answer is a warning sign. The city’s Office of Labor Standards Enforcement (OLSE) enforces the ordinance.
What the City Rule Keeps Off the Table
Even after an offer, some records cannot be asked about or considered. Those include arrests that did not lead to a conviction (unresolved arrests are treated differently), diversion programs, dismissed or expunged convictions, juvenile matters, and infractions. Convictions more than seven years old, counted from the sentencing date, are also out, unless the job involves supervising minors or dependent adults. So a clean report in San Francisco does not mean a person has no history at all. It means the report shows what the law lets an employer use.
What Changed in August 2026
Amendments to the ordinance took effect on August 10, 2026, so older hiring paperwork may be out of date. The city now bars employers from using out-of-state convictions for conduct that is lawful in California, such as abortion-related healthcare and gender-affirming care. Employers must confirm receipt of evidence an applicant submits within 14 days and give notice of a final decision within 30 days. Administrative penalties also went up, to $1,000 per affected person for a first violation and up to $4,000 for later ones. Asking a provider whether its forms were updated this year is a simple test of whether anyone is paying attention.
How the City and State Rules Fit Together
California’s Fair Chance Act has applied since January 1, 2018, to employers with five or more employees, and San Francisco employers must comply with both laws. The state law requires an individualized look at the nature and gravity of the offense, the time that has passed, and the nature of the job. The table below compares the two as a buyer would want to see them. Where they differ, the company has to meet each one.
| Stage | San Francisco Fair Chance Ordinance | California Fair Chance Act |
|---|---|---|
| Who is covered | Five or more employees; jobs of at least eight hours a week in the city | Five or more employees |
| Earliest time to ask | After a conditional offer | After a conditional offer |
| Older convictions | Over seven years from sentencing is off-limits, with a narrow exception | Time passed is weighed in the assessment |
| Before rejecting someone | Notice of the proposed action and the items behind it | Written notice with the conviction report, if there is one |
| Time to respond | Seven days, per OLSE guidance | At least five business days, plus five more if the person disputes accuracy in writing and is gathering evidence |
| Final step | Final decision notice within 30 days | Written final notice, including the right to file a complaint with the state |
Consent and Reports Come Before the Search
If a company buys a report from a screening firm, federal and state consumer reporting laws apply as well. The Federal Trade Commission says the employer must give written notice in a stand-alone format and get written permission first. California’s Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act also calls for a stand-alone disclosure and written authorization. Under Civil Code section 1786.16, the applicant gets a box to check to request a copy, which must arrive within three business days of the employer receiving it. Section 1786.18 generally stops reporting agencies from listing conviction records older than seven years.
A Fair Process Before Anyone Is Turned Down
A negative report does not end the matter under any of these laws. Federal rules call for a pre-adverse notice with a copy of the report and a summary of the person’s rights, so errors can be caught. A mismatched name or someone else’s record can cost a good worker a job if nobody checks. A company that can walk you through this sequence is likely running a real program. A company that cannot may be guessing, and that uncertainty could turn into a staffing gap on your account.
Why a “No Record, No Exceptions” Clause Backfires
Some buyers want a line in the service agreement saying no one with a criminal record may enter the building. Both city and state law push employers toward individual review, with attention on whether a conviction relates to the job. State regulations also treat “No Felons” style statements in job ads as a problem. A flat demand can leave the company stuck between your clause and its legal duties. Write down what you need instead, such as a described screening process, named crew members and restricted areas, and ask your counsel to review the wording.
What Vetting Should Cover Beyond a Criminal Search
A criminal search is only one part of knowing who is in your office. Identity confirmation, past employment and references often say more about whether someone shows up and follows instructions. Training on your site’s alarm, keys and off-limits areas matters as much as any record. The same standard should also apply to everyone, because the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission treats uneven screening as evidence of discrimination. Ask how the company decides someone is ready to work unsupervised.
Fill-Ins, Weekend Crews and Specialty Visits
Most gaps show up on the night your regular cleaner is out. The screened person you met at the walkthrough may not be the person a supervisor sends on a Friday, and floor or window visits may bring new faces. Ask whether the same process applies to every person the company sends into your suite. Ask how you will be told about a substitute, and whether that person’s name reaches your building’s security desk first. A supervisor who knows your account should be able to answer without looking it up.
How Your Building and Industry Change the Answer
A Financial District tower may require named crew lists and badges through its property manager, so vetting and access planning go together. A SoMa tech office or Mission Bay lab may want some rooms closed to cleaners entirely. Medical suites and financial firms can fall under separate rules, and the city’s ordinance gives way where another federal or state law requires a check. Tell the cleaning company about these requirements before work starts, not after. Our office cleaning and overnight cleaning pages describe how those services run in the city.
Questions to Ask Any San Francisco Cleaning Company
Use these during a walkthrough or in a proposal request. Good answers will be short and specific. Vague ones deserve a follow-up.
- What steps does a new hire go through, and in what order?
- When in hiring does the criminal check take place?
- Which records does the check search, and how far back?
- Were your forms and notices updated after the August 2026 amendments?
- Does the process apply to substitutes, weekend staff and specialty visits?
- Who will be assigned to our site, and how will we hear about changes?
- Who controls keys, badges and alarm codes, and what happens when someone leaves?
- Who is the single contact if we have a concern about a crew member?
Vetting Continues After the Hire
A check shows a moment in time, so supervision does the rest of the work. Regular site inspections, sign-in records, and prompt collection of keys and badges when someone leaves protect you more than any report. The FTC notes that if an employer wants authorization to last through employment, the form must say so clearly, so ask whether the company re-screens, on what basis, and how it handles a complaint about a crew member. For larger properties, our building cleaning services page explains how a multi-floor program is organized. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Talk to American Janitorial Services (San Francisco)
If you are reviewing your cleaning program or planning a change, American Janitorial Services (San Francisco) can walk your space and go through crew, access and supervision questions with you. Call (415) 417-1850, email info@janitorial-sf.com, or visit us at 505 Montgomery St, Ste 1051, Floor 1, San Francisco, CA 94111.
Sources
- City and County of San Francisco, OLSE: Fair Chance Ordinance
- CalChamber: San Francisco Expands Fair Chance Ordinance (August 2026)
- National Law Review: San Francisco Amends Its Fair Chance Ordinance (August 2026)
- California Government Code section 12952
- California Civil Rights Department: Fair Chance Act
- Epstein Becker Green: California’s Amended Regulations (2023)
- California Civil Code section 1786.16
- California Civil Code section 1786.18
- FTC: Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know
- EEOC: Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know
